Home Learn to Trade Why Use a Dark Pool? A Guide to Dark Pool Investing

Why Use a Dark Pool? A Guide to Dark Pool Investing

by admin

Dark pools are personal exchanges for trading securities, which are not available for the investing public. It also called “dark pools of liquidity,” the name of these trades refers to their complete lack of transparency. Dark pools facilitated block trading by institutional investors who did not wish to impact the markets with large orders. Dark pools may sound negative, but they serve a purpose by allowing big trades to proceed without affecting the broader market. But, their lack of transparency makes them weak to potential conflicts of interest by their owners. Some high-frequency traders do the trading in dark pool exchange.

Understanding of dark pools

Dark pools were introduced in the 1980s when the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) enabled brokers to transact many shares. In2007, the SEC introduced the dark pool concept to increase competition and cut transaction charges. Since they have increased the number of dark pools, they can charge fewer fees than exchanges because they are grouped within a large firm and not with a bank. The direct advantage of dark pool trading is that investors can also make scaling in trading without disclosing the price. It controls heavy price depreciation, which would otherwise arise. For example, if an investment bank is selling 50,000 shares, the share would decrease in price by the time the bank finds buyers for securities. Depreciation has become a risk, and electronic trading platforms cause expenses to respond to market pressures.

A Guide to Dark Pool Investing

There are few major reasons why one may prefer dark pool trading. “Stock analyst” might not show this in the conversation at a party. “Dark pool traders” likely drive motorcycles to work at an unknown location. No one will be aware of your work, this is because of some security reasons. The second, more realistic reason is to conduct trades without affecting the market. Dark pool investing is a straightforward answer to a common situation. Yet, it’s not a problem many retail investors will have, Here’s a breakdown of dark pool investing.

Understanding dark pool investing:

Dark pools, also called Alternative Trading Systems (ATS) are legal private security markets. In a dark pool trading system, investors place orders without disclosing their trade price or the number of stocks.



Dark pool trades are “over the counter.” which means that the stocks are traded straight between the buyer and seller, with the help of a broker. Instead of depending on public exchange pricing, traders reach their price agreements confidentially. There are three types of dark pools: broker-dealer-owned, agency broker, and electronic market makers. Broker-dealers set up the first type for their clients, including proprietary trading. These prices come from their order flow. The second acts like an agent rather than a principal, and there is no price discovery as the costs come from exchanges. Independent operators offer the last type, and there is no price discovery.

Dark pool exchanges keep their secrecy because of this over-the-counter pattern. Neither party has to reveal any price information unless specific conditions push them. 


What Are The Various Types Of Dark Pools?


According to the most current data, there are 50+ dark pools registered with the securities and exchange commission. 

 Broker-Dealer-Owned Dark Pool

Large broker-dealers set up these dark pools for their clients and include their proprietary traders. These dark pools obtain their prices from order flow, so price discovery is essential.

  • Credit Suisse’s Cross Finder
  • Goldman Sachs’ Sigma X
  • Citibank’s Citi-Match
  • Morgan Stanley’s M.S. Pool

These are some examples of dark pools.


Agency Broker or Exchange-Owned Dark Pool

These are dark pools that work as agents, not as principals. There is no price as prices originate from exchanges, such as the National Best Bid and Offer. Examples of agency broker dark pools include:

  • Instinet
  • Liquidnet
  • ITG Posit, while exchange-owned dark pools include those offered by BATS Trading and NYSE Euronext


Electronic Market Makers Dark Pools

These are dark pools suggested by independent operators who perform as principals for their accounts. For broker-dealer-owned dark pools, the transaction prices are not counted by NBBO, so price discovery occurs.


Mention Some Advantages of Dark pools stock market


The importance of dark pools makes it necessary to understand trading strategies. Yet, as the name suggests, many of the specific details on what they are and how they operate remain unclear. Exponents of dark pools often claim many benefits, many of which are grounded in the pools’ facelessness. Supporters claim dark pools are more reliable, especially when compared to public exchanges, and it is cost-effective and gives participants space and control. Some advantages of dark pools stock market are as follows:


Price Improvement

Dark pool buyers believe that dark pools are discretionary. It gives brokers the freedom to choose the time and place of execution. Often, when acting for clients, brokers first check dark pools. The order is executed if any sell orders are priced below clients’ buy requirements. A successful order that matches both the sellers’ and buyers’ price requirements is profitable. There are various types of profitable forex strategies to win-lose or zero-sum situations. If this scenario does not exist, brokers buy their clients’ orders on traditional markets or at the market price. Thus, clients believe they receive healthy prices from dark pools, even if the exact price is not revealed.


Lower Transaction Costs

Dark pools’ transaction costs are often less due to two forms of transaction savings. First, dark pools often suppress the routing transactions to external markets. For instance, there is no need to reroute in ping destinations, where customers only contact the pool operator’s orders; these are often in broker-dealer pools. It is also the case with internalization, which is used in broker-dealer pools like Credit Suisse. In this case, sellers and buyers are matched and do not route to external markets.

Second, dark pools discount big orders. For example, Liquidnet gives investors discounts when they sell in large quantities and more irregular transactions. The lower costs of essentially wholesaling a share or product is a reality that is reflected in many industries.



Dark pools manage and adjust their liquidity. Some dark pools type orders are based on their toxicity. For instance, Barclays’s pool types toxicity based on many items, such as pricing or how an order compares to matching orders. Other examples include ITG’s Posit, a point-in-time crossing method, and Knight Capital’s which uses equal division. Each dark pool has different approaches to differentiate itself from the rest. It cannot be a complete list of all the monitoring strategies. Yet, the point is that dark pools’ methods inspire trust among traders.


Other Benefits

The first three advantages discussed above are the most referenced. Dark pool followers consider other minor, less publicized advantages, resulting from pools’ unique features and differences from public exchanges. For instance, as supporters concentrate on the benefits for large traders, the gains of small investors go unrecognized. Small investors who use 401(k)s and mutual funds may please as their trades are often bundled into big orders.


How Dark Pools Affect Individual Investors


There’s no realistic case that an average retail trader will move the market. Your market influence will not impact other investors unless you have an extensive portfolio. You can buy a company’s shares which will affect your share prices. But it won’t be at any measurable capacity. As a result, a retail investor has little use for dark pool investments, Despite the popularity of dark pool trading in recent years. 

The dark pool investing system has become one of the most popular ways to trade stock markets. The markets are made more efficient by growing the share of the trading value amount of the dark pool by a specific level. Yet, increasing the percentage above the class makes the market inefficient. It indicates that the dark pool has an optimal usage rate for market efficiency. The order routing communicates market orders to the dark collection, which causes the depth orders to be broader. The broader limit orders grip up the orders of the market. Hence a market price is still stable near an actual price.

So, for many times orders are safely kept in the dark pool. The charges absorb market orders and prevent the market price from converging to the actual price. It causes the market price to stay very different from the actual price, while making it inefficient. We also discussed tools by which a dark pool makes a market efficient or inefficient using a simple equation model. The equations state that markets become weak if the trading value is higher in dark pools rather than in markets. It indicates that when the usage of dark pools is low, dark pools rarely beat the price discovery even though a large buy-sell imbalance occurs. On the other hand, when the usage rate of dark pools is very high, dark pools quickly beat the price discovery by a very slight buy-sell imbalance. We also compared the results of the equations with those of simulations and found equal tendencies. At last it said that this dark pool system is suitable for big investors rather than the small ones. 


Ten Things You Should Know About Dark Pools


Dark pools have become a large part of the international equity markets. They’ve become an actual competitor and alternative to traditional stock markets. Many investors are dizzy about dark pools because of rumors, which isn’t surprising. Just the name is enough to put worry into anyone interested in them. Because there is little knowledge of what happens in dark pools, these ten things are essential to know. It will help you understand how they impact the markets and affect your equity trades.

1) It is not a “Black Market.” It’s just not displayed. Many comments in the media say that Dark Pools are the “wild west.” Many Customers are manipulated, that brokers make tons of money, but that is not always true. 

2)If you think that these dark pools are something new in the market, but that is not true because dark pools were always around since trading started, it’s just that this terminology represents as “overhead trading” in the past.

3) Dark Pools are highly controlled. All Dark Pools are dealers and brokers registered with the Security Exchange Commission and The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority. And it is subject to regular audits and examinations as an exchange.

4) The Securities and Exchange Commission has identified the importance for institutions to work on orders without displaying the whole order.

5) Users choose to place their orders in a Dark Pool. The users are wise traders who understand the advantages of not showing their orders at an exchange.

6) The National Best Bid offer binds Dark Pool trades. Prices are not random as it is the core of NBBO. You can not trade this stock outside the NBBO.

7)The stocks trade more volume in the dark pool because it operates for the institutions. 

8) Different Dark Pools have various elements to attract various market segments.

9) Orders in dark pools are like icebergs. A resting bid, or buyer, must be present for a trade to occur when a seller initiates a sale. Both sides are not present at the exact moment as orders are canceled and replaced. These orders are referred to as “ships passing in the night.”

10) The most important reason people fear “Dark Pools” is its name, which sounds risky.


The Bottom Line:


Dark pool investing isn’t something an average retail investor will participate in, and it may be helpful for institutional investors and firms. When large-scale investors buy or sell an extensive stock, other investors could do the same, influencing the entire market, so dark pool trading helps control that from happening. Yet, there is still a considerable risk with this investment.

Also, Read Some Interesting Information About, Great Mechanical Trading Systems That Aid Success.

You may also like